#  History of Philosophy Workshop: Colin Chamberlain (UCL), "After the Fall: Malebranche on the Law of the Body" 

 



####  calendar\_today Date and Time 

 **October 11, 2025** 

 10:00AM - 12:00PM EDT 

####  pin\_drop Location 

 **Robbins Library, Emerson 211**  



 

 



 

Abstract: Malebranche claims that the Fall changes the mind’s relationship to the body from *union* to *dependence*. He often describes this change in normative terms: the Fall deprives the mind of its authority to rule the body and puts the body in charge instead. While these normative claims might seem to conflict with Malebranche’s hierarchical vision of reality that ranks the mind above the body, I argue that they express his considered view. Original sin confers authority on the body to command the mind, and the body exercises this authority via the mediation of the senses. As a result of the Fall, the senses speak with the force of law when they urge the mind to care for the body’s needs. Malebranche holds that a perception—a mental representation that things are thus and so—becomes a *command* for the mind, obliging it to assent, when the perception is enforced by inner sanctions. A perception *commands* the mind when the mind feels pain in withholding assent, pleasure when giving it. I argue that, after the Fall, the senses command in just this way. Sensory perceptions are accompanied by inner sanctions—feelings of pleasure and pain—that imbue them with obligatory force.



 

 



 

 

 Share on:- [     Facebook ](#)
- [     Twitter ](#)
- [     Linkedin ](#)
 


 Save: [ Add to calendar calendar\_today ](https://mcdonough.scholars.harvard.edu/node/782801/event-feed.ics)  Copy link link